— This blog was originally published on International Women’s Day 2018 —
Jeeeeeez, what a week. I usually shy away from topics like this but frankly, after the last couple of days, I’m pretty mad at the world. I’ve faced sexism in my fave queer pub, been told I should kill myself by an idiotic transphobic troll and watched as a RuPaul used an interview in the Guardian to delegitimize not only my drag but that of my fellow trans and non-binary performers. So considering all of this and the fact that today is International Women’s Day, I decided to channel my energy here and give my own personal perspective on this subject. I often get asked (primarily by cis straight men) “can women be drag queens” but it’s a question I don’t feel I have to answer. It isn’t my responsibility to be the educator because I’m essentially being asked to defend my existence. But then it made me think: what does your average lovely person do when they want to understand a subject but don’t want to potentially insult someone? They Google it. So if you’ve ended up here to self-educate, then I feel pretty happy to help out. Here’s a short guide to this drag(ing) debate and the question that won’t go away. The answer to which is simply:
I exist. Therefore, yes. End of story really. And I’m not the only woman who performs drag. Thousands of femme-bodied performers across the planet do drag, in many various forms. But before I get onto that, let’s take a moment to talk about gender. If terms like ‘cis’ or ‘non-binary’ aren’t something you’ve come across before or you aren’t so sure you understand yet, that’s ok and I definitely encourage you to read up on this first. I recommend Sam Dylan Finch’s Transgender 101 guide on Everyday Feminism as an excellent place to start. I also want to point out that I can really only talk about my own lived experience as up until now (mixed with lashings of queer and gender theory from that dusty old degree I did nearly two decades ago) and other drag performers will have different perspectives on this debate to me. I’ve added some pictures throughout this blog with quotes from other performers, so just click on these to check them out. Plus there’s a further reading list at the end so you can hear from other writers too. It’s also worth noting that terms used and attitudes towards subjects like gender, drag and feminism are constantly evolving, so my current viewpoint could easily seem a little outdated in a few years. So read on with an open mind.
As I mentioned before, it’s International Women’s Day and I feel it’s more important than ever to think about why we are asking this in the first place. Why do we always question what women can do? Especially when it comes to careers/spheres/practises/lifestyles that have traditionally been male-dominated? What is it that makes us want to limit the world of women? Can’t the answer to these questions always simply be “why not?” Why are women always being asked to justify their lives in ways men never are? Just think of all the things we could accomplish if we didn’t have to address questions like this all the bloody time…
“Let’s get one thing clear – you absolutely do not need validation from RuPaul.”
What my drag is to me
“Oh, so you’re a woman, impersonating a man, impersonating a woman” is often a bit of rough logic thrown my way when I mention I do drag. Funnily enough, though, men don’t really have much to with my drag queen performances. To me, drag is a hyper-performance of gender; a fun exploration of these ridiculous notions of ‘men’ and ‘women’ that society thinks we should perform in our everyday lives. So naturally, I’ve found drag to be one the best platforms for me to express what my own experience of being a woman is. I’ve explored everything from perceptions of female arousal to the everyday acceptance of violence against women in my shows. By transforming myself, my face, my body into this extreme idea of how we think women should appear and behave gives me the chance to address what being a “woman” is.
I had an incredibly long gestational period before becoming a drag performer and a lot of time to think about why I wanted to do it and what I wanted to convey through it as a medium. TBH I suppose a lot of drag performers probably don’t think about it all quite this much. But I do take this colourful and non-conforming world very seriously: it’s a life-long passion and a really important performative medium to me. A powerful feature of drag is that it’s irreverent and joyful at the same time as being very emotional. In one sense it’s a bit of outrageous fun mixed with a whole load of make-up, wigs and interesting footwear; and in another, it’s a provocative, radical act that attempts to disrupt this binary world that we live in. My partner, who has been performing drag longer than I have, describes it as a superpower because it transforms you into an icon that inspires reverence. And if there’s one thing we need to be giving women, it’s more superpowers.
“15 years years ago I intended to reclaim over-the-top femininity to the female body and fuck with gender stereotypes. And my dear, I’m still here.
But sod me. Trans women, all women, everybody has the right to play. Keep trucking kids. Do you.”
So what do I call women who are drag queens?
Drag queens. That’s the really easy bit. You’ll hear lots of terms bandied about – bio queen, faux queen, female drag queen etc – but all these words do is demean what some drag queens do and indicate that they’re not equal to other drag queens – even though we’re sharing the same stage, doing the same shows, all doing drag. I (currently) like the term “femme-bodied drag queens” when having a discussion that requires you to differentiate because it acknowledges that we aren’t simply working with a binary of male and female but there’s a whole big, beautiful spectrum of gender that we need to acknowledge.
“To embody a set of cultural constructs historically associated with women, a lot of the time at the comedic expense of women, while excluding women, within a sex-gender system which disproportionately causes violence towards women – especially trans, women of colour & gender-nonconforming individuals – is a perfect example of how unapologetically/self-righteously patriarchal, misogynist and even colonial attitudes are freely perpetuated within gay culture.”
Arguments against women being drag queens
One argument against women performing as drag queens makes me laugh because it sounds so familiar – just in reverse. Back when I was first introduced to the queer activist world at university (many moons ago), there was a lot of debate about drag queens and how they exploited the sexism in our society, copying the world of women for a cheap laugh and particularly co-opting the culture of black and Latino women. I agree that there are some incredibly sexist and racist drag performers out there (I talk about the difference between progressive and offensive drag below) but for me, feminism was never about holding onto the social constructs that we identify as ‘female’ and not letting anyone else touch them. If someone who doesn’t identify as a woman wants to wear make-up, dresses and heels, I’m all for it. But to then be told that me performing as a drag queen co-opts gay male culture is laughable. Exactly who were you pretending to be in the first place? It’s also interesting that it’s specifically the culture of gay men is apparently being co-opted. Whilst we’ve long used the term LGBT+ to refer to the queer community, it has always been dominated by gay men, while lesbians, bisexuals, trans people and everyone else who fitted under this umbrella term were routinely sidelined. So this is not the inclusivity and diversity of queer culture that they seek to protect but the exclusivity of the gay male community – one which is renowned for being incredibly sexist, racist and ableist. So why in this day and age would we want to protect something that serves only cis gay men and shuts everyone else out?
“Yes, drag most definitely is a ‘fuck you’ to toxic masculinity and the male-dominated society but would you look at the gender most of us are portraying? FEMALE. What type of person inspires our characters/personas? WOMEN. To discourage women or shut them out of drag CONSCIOUSLY is backwards.”
RuPaul has often been quoted as saying “I do not impersonate females! How many women do you know who wear seven-inch heels, four-foot wigs, and skintight dresses?” Ummm… hello? Has he never met Cher? But seriously, it’s insulting to the intelligence of everyone in the room when drag queens try and suggest this. I mean, we all know you’re not shopping in the kids or the sports department – you’re heading straight for the women’s section. So let’s ponder this: if drag queens are not supposed to be impersonating women, then what could be the issue with a woman performing as a drag queen? If it’s not a performance of our gender, then why can’t we impersonate it too? Either way, it is and it’s totally legitimate for us to embrace it too. As with so many of these arguments, they are hollow and make no sense. What is clear though is that these arguments are mainly about shutting women up and shutting them out.
Finally, one of the other arguments against women being drag queens is that it’s not considered radical or punk enough. Well, in the age of a mainstream TV show that exclusively shows male drag queens, this limited definition of what a drag queen can be doesn’t feel that radical. If you want to see truly punk drag, you have to go to a venue that shows a broad spectrum of drag performers (be they men, women or non-binary). By holding on tight to this restrictive idea that only men can be drag queens raises an awful lot of questions too. Is it only gay men (because there’s a long history of straight men doing drag)? Is it only cis men or can trans men be drag queens (and at what point in their transition does this suddenly become “acceptable”)? Are trans women allowed to perform as drag queens (because a number of contestants on RuPaul’s Drag Race have transitioned since the show)? Or at what point do these arguments and restrictions fall apart and we shout WHO BLOODY CARES? Seriously. Why so much effort to shut out everyone who aren’t “men”?
“Ru(Paul) as a cis man having conversations about, and rule over, women’s bodies is alarmingly in line with the current swing of conservative politics. Also the public erasure of trans women from the history of drag and then the irony of Ru, a male, telling women, cis and trans, they can’t do drag because it’s not as big of a fuck you to a male-dominated world. Very controversial…”
Where to continue your drag education
Just as there are a whole variety of people who can and do perform as drag queens, there’s a broad range of types of drag, from progressive to incredibly bigoted. I’ve walked out of some eye-wateringly sexist and racist drags shows in the past two decades, where drag queens have derided vaginas or performed crude racial stereotypes for cheap laughs. This is not my drag and it shouldn’t be yours. The future of drag is with performers who challenge rather than uphold the system and with venues that embrace a wide variety of drags performers, both kings and queens, of all gender variants. If you’ve only ever watched RuPaul’s Drag Race and never been to a show in your local area, then it’s time to do some fieldwork in your quest for self-education. Research the performers and venues nearby. Are the shows full of predominantly white, male performers or is the line-up mixed? If you want to really understand where drag is at now, you’ll find it on the stages that are shared by women and non-binary performers too.
Finally, I wanted to say that this is not a time for division. We have to unite with inclusivity to fight the powers that still oppress us all, rather than wield any privilege we may have (be is male, white or cis) against each other.
Hopefully, this helps debunk this question for you and I’ll see you at my next show!
- How drag queen Victoria Sin is tackling notions of binary and fixed gender by Christina Ko (South China Morning Post)
- Meet the Trans, Non-Binary and Bio Queens Who Deserve a Spot on ‘RuPaul’s Drag Race U.K.’ by Rae Alexandra (KQED)
- From Drags to Bitches: The implications of mainstreamed drag culture on women by Liz Cohen (Medium)
- Does UK Drag Have a Misogyny Problem? by Ben Charlie Smoke (Vice)
- Why do some people want to stop women performing drag? by Jake Hall (Dazed)
- No, RuPaul, the drag queen world does not only belong to men – everyone can explore femininity by Amrou Al-Kadhi (Independent)
- Meet The Female Queen Shattering Drag’s Rhinestone Ceiling by Alex Black (Into)
- I’m a trans woman and a drag queen. Despite what RuPaul says, you can be both by Monica Beverly Hillz (The Washington Post)
- Talking race and intersectionality in drag with Victoria Sin by Jake Hall (i-D)
- No Girls Allowed: Examining the Validity of the Bio Queen and Their Role in Queer Environments by China Dethcrash (Hiskind)
- Workin’ it! How female drag queens are causing a scene by Rebecca Nicholson (Guardian)